Shopping for a compact SUV often means choosing between strong options. Two of the most popular picks are the Buick Encore and the Jeep Cherokee.
Both offer unique strengths, but they suit different drivers and lifestyles. If you’re deciding between these models, it’s important to look beyond surface features.
This guide compares the Encore and Cherokee in real-world ways, so you can find the vehicle that fits your needs best.
Design And Comfort
The Buick Encore is known for its small size and easy handling. It’s perfect for city driving and tight parking spots. The Encore’s design is modern and stylish, with smooth lines and a compact look. Inside, the cabin feels upscale for its price. Soft-touch materials, quiet ride, and comfortable seating for four adults make short trips pleasant.
The Jeep Cherokee, by contrast, is larger and looks more rugged. Its design shows off traditional Jeep features, like a seven-slot grille and higher ground clearance. Inside, the Cherokee offers more space, especially in the rear seats and cargo area. The materials are tough, and higher trims add luxury touches. It’s a better choice if you often have passengers or need extra room for gear.
Performance And Handling
Performance is where these SUVs start to show their differences. Here’s a quick comparison:
| Model | Base Engine | Horsepower | Drivetrain |
|---|---|---|---|
| Buick Encore | 1.4L Turbo I4 | 155 hp | FWD / AWD |
| Jeep Cherokee | 2.4L I4 | 180 hp | FWD / AWD / 4WD |
The Encore focuses on efficiency. Its turbo engine provides enough power for city and light highway driving, but it’s not designed for speed. The Encore’s suspension is soft, so bumps are less noticeable. However, when you drive faster or carry a full load, the engine can feel underpowered.
The Cherokee offers more engine choices, including a powerful V6. Even the base engine gives stronger acceleration than the Encore. The Cherokee is also available with advanced all-wheel drive and true four-wheel drive, making it a favorite for off-road or snowy conditions. If you want a vehicle for adventure, the Cherokee stands out.
Technology And Safety
Both vehicles include modern technology, but with some key differences.
- Buick Encore: Includes a standard 7-inch touchscreen, Apple CarPlay and Android Auto, Wi-Fi hotspot, and basic driver-assist features like rearview camera and available blind-spot monitoring.
- Jeep Cherokee: Offers a larger 8.4-inch touchscreen, more USB ports, and advanced driver aids like adaptive cruise control, lane-keeping assist, and automatic emergency braking on higher trims.
One thing beginners might miss is that while both models offer safety tech, most advanced features on the Encore are only available on the highest trim or as options. The Cherokee, especially in recent years, includes more driver-assist features even in mid-level trims.
Fuel Economy And Ownership Costs
Gas mileage is important for many buyers. Here’s how the two compare:
| Model | City MPG | Highway MPG | Annual Fuel Cost (est.) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Buick Encore | 24 | 32 | $1,700 |
| Jeep Cherokee | 22 | 31 | $1,850 |
The Buick Encore wins in fuel economy. Its smaller engine means fewer trips to the gas station. This adds up if you drive a lot. Maintenance costs are also lower, and parts for the Encore are easy to find.
The Cherokee uses more gas, especially with bigger engines or four-wheel drive. Insurance rates can also be higher. However, Cherokee’s resale value tends to stay strong, especially for off-road trims. One insight: buyers often overlook the impact of bigger tires and heavier weight on Cherokee’s real-world fuel costs.
Cargo Space And Practicality
You might be surprised by how much cargo space matters, even in compact SUVs. Here’s a head-to-head look:
| Model | Cargo (Seats Up) | Cargo (Seats Down) |
|---|---|---|
| Buick Encore | 18.8 cu ft | 48.4 cu ft |
| Jeep Cherokee | 25.8 cu ft | 54.7 cu ft |
The Cherokee is the better choice if you carry lots of luggage, sports gear, or pets. The split-folding rear seats and wide opening make loading easy. The Encore is enough for groceries, small bags, or two carry-on suitcases, but you’ll feel the limit on bigger trips.
Reliability And Owner Satisfaction
Reliability is a key factor for long-term peace of mind. The Buick Encore often scores above average in reliability surveys. Its simple mechanics and proven engine mean fewer unexpected repairs. Owners praise the Encore for low maintenance and good dealer support.
The Jeep Cherokee has improved in recent years, but older models had some issues, especially with transmissions. Newer Cherokees are more reliable, but regular maintenance is important. If you plan to keep your SUV for many years, the Encore is a safer bet for trouble-free ownership.
Which Should You Choose?
Choosing between the Buick Encore and Jeep Cherokee depends on your daily needs. The Encore is best for city driving, easy parking, and drivers who want low ownership costs. It’s perfect for singles, couples, or small families who don’t need a lot of cargo space.
The Cherokee is better for those who want more power, extra space, and the option to go off-road. If you often drive in snow, tow small trailers, or need to fit more passengers, the Cherokee is worth the higher price and fuel costs.
One mistake buyers make is choosing based only on price or features. Think about your lifestyle: Do you need off-road ability? Will you use the extra cargo room? Test drive both and check real-world reviews, like those from Edmunds, before deciding.
Frequently Asked Questions
<!– wp:rank-math/faq-block {"questions":[{"id":"faq-question-d4e4d58316f7","title":"Is The Buick Encore Or Jeep Cherokee Better For Families?","content":"The Jeep Cherokee is usually better for families. It offers more rear seat space and cargo room, so kids and luggage fit easier.
“,”visible”:true},{“id”:”faq-question-1ae5b095badc”,”title”:”Which Suv Is Safer?”,”content”:”Both are safe, but the Jeep Cherokee offers more advanced driver-assistance features on most trims. The Encore is also highly rated but has fewer standard safety aids.
“,”visible”:true},{“id”:”faq-question-6348ad9d5fe9″,”title”:”How Do The Encore And Cherokee Compare In Winter Driving?”,”content”:”The Cherokee is stronger for winter. Its advanced all-wheel drive and higher ground clearance handle snow and ice better than the Encore.
“,”visible”:true},{“id”:”faq-question-c0d72e5e1d8e”,”title”:”Which Has Higher Resale Value?”,”content”:”The Jeep Cherokee often holds value better, especially the off-road or high-trim models. The Encore’s value drops faster after a few years.
“,”visible”:true},{“id”:”faq-question-1fab4c27eb16″,”title”:”Are These Vehicles Expensive To Maintain?”,”content”:”The Buick Encore has lower maintenance costs. The Cherokee can be more costly, especially if you use all-wheel or four-wheel drive features often.
Choosing between these SUVs is about finding the right fit for your life. Compare what matters most, and you’ll end up with a vehicle you enjoy every day.
“,”visible”:true}]} –>Is The Buick Encore Or Jeep Cherokee Better For Families?
The Jeep Cherokee is usually better for families. It offers more rear seat space and cargo room, so kids and luggage fit easier.
Which Suv Is Safer?
Both are safe, but the Jeep Cherokee offers more advanced driver-assistance features on most trims. The Encore is also highly rated but has fewer standard safety aids.
How Do The Encore And Cherokee Compare In Winter Driving?
The Cherokee is stronger for winter. Its advanced all-wheel drive and higher ground clearance handle snow and ice better than the Encore.
Which Has Higher Resale Value?
The Jeep Cherokee often holds value better, especially the off-road or high-trim models. The Encore’s value drops faster after a few years.
Are These Vehicles Expensive To Maintain?
The Buick Encore has lower maintenance costs. The Cherokee can be more costly, especially if you use all-wheel or four-wheel drive features often.
Choosing between these SUVs is about finding the right fit for your life. Compare what matters most, and you’ll end up with a vehicle you enjoy every day.
