Why Not To Buy A Jeep Cherokee: Top Reasons to Avoid

Some links on this site are affiliate links. If you make a purchase, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Your support helps keep our content free.

Buying a car is a big decision. Many people consider the Jeep Cherokee because it looks tough and offers good features.

However, there are important reasons why you may want to avoid buying a Jeep Cherokee. If you want a reliable, safe, and cost-effective SUV, you should know its real-world problems before making your choice.

This article helps you understand why the Jeep Cherokee might not be the best option for you. You’ll also see facts, comparisons, and answers to common questions.

why not to buy a jeep cherokee

Reliability Issues

The Jeep Cherokee has a history of mechanical problems. According to Consumer Reports, the Cherokee often ranks below average for reliability. Many owners report issues with the transmission, especially in models from 2014–2019. Some transmission repairs can cost over $2,500.

Another common problem is with the electrical system. Drivers experience random warning lights, malfunctioning displays, and trouble starting the engine. In the long run, these problems can lead to frequent trips to the mechanic and high repair bills.

Reliability Comparison

Here’s a look at how the Jeep Cherokee compares to other popular SUVs on reliability:

ModelReliability Score (out of 5)Common Issues
Jeep Cherokee2.0Transmission, Electrical
Toyota RAV44.5Minor Interior
Honda CR-V4.2Brake Wear
Ford Escape3.8Engine Cooling

You can see that the Cherokee falls behind its main competitors.

High Maintenance Costs

Jeep Cherokees often need expensive repairs. Parts for Jeeps cost more than average, and labor can be higher. According to RepairPal, the average annual maintenance cost for a Jeep Cherokee is about $520. This is higher than the Toyota RAV4 ($429) and Honda CR-V ($407).

Some repairs are more frequent. For example, the 2014 2019 models face recurring transmission issues.

Owners also complain about oil leaks and faulty sensors. If you’re looking for low-cost ownership, the Cherokee is not ideal.

Maintenance Cost Comparison

Let’s compare maintenance costs for popular SUVs:

ModelAnnual Maintenance CostRepair Frequency
Jeep Cherokee$520High
Toyota RAV4$429Low
Honda CR-V$407Low
Ford Escape$456Medium

If you want to save money over time, other SUVs are clearly better.

Why Not To Buy A Jeep Cherokee: Top Reasons to Avoid

Safety Concerns

Safety is important for any car buyer. The Jeep Cherokee has received average safety ratings. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) gives most Cherokees a four-star rating, while competitors like the Toyota RAV4 and Honda CR-V often earn five stars.

Cherokee’s crash test results show weak performance in side impact and roof strength tests. Some models also lack advanced safety features like automatic emergency braking and lane-keeping assist, which are now standard in other SUVs.

Safety Feature Comparison

Here’s how the Cherokee’s safety features stack up:

ModelAutomatic Emergency BrakingLane Keeping AssistBlind Spot Monitoring
Jeep CherokeeOptionalOptionalOptional
Toyota RAV4StandardStandardStandard
Honda CR-VStandardStandardStandard
Ford EscapeStandardStandardOptional

Buying a Cherokee means you may have to pay extra for features that competitors include for free.

Poor Fuel Economy

Fuel costs matter, especially if you drive often. The Jeep Cherokee is not very fuel-efficient. Most models get about 22 mpg city and 30 mpg highway. In comparison, the Toyota RAV4 gets up to 27 mpg city and 35 mpg highway.

Over time, this difference adds up. If you drive 15,000 miles per year, you’ll pay about $400 more in fuel with a Cherokee compared to a RAV4.

This is a hidden cost many buyers overlook.

Why Not To Buy A Jeep Cherokee: Top Reasons to Avoid


Depreciation And Resale Value

Cars lose value over time, but the Cherokee loses value faster than most. According to Kelley Blue Book, a Jeep Cherokee can lose up to 48% of its value in five years.

The Toyota RAV4, on the other hand, loses about 36% in the same period.

This means you’ll get less money when you sell your Cherokee. If you plan to upgrade in the future, this is an important factor.

Non-obvious Insights

Many buyers do not realize that Jeep Cherokees also have limited aftermarket support. It’s harder to find cheap replacement parts or upgrade options compared to more popular SUVs like the Honda CR-V. Another overlooked problem is road noise. Cherokees are often louder on highways, which can be uncomfortable on long trips.

Alternatives To Consider

If you’re looking for a reliable, safe, and cost-effective SUV, consider these alternatives:

  • Toyota RAV4 – High reliability, strong resale value, great fuel economy.
  • Honda CR-V – Smooth ride, excellent safety, affordable maintenance.
  • Mazda CX-5 – Stylish design, sporty handling, good reliability.
  • Ford Escape – Competitive price, good features, decent reliability.

Researching these models can help you find an SUV that fits your needs without the problems of a Jeep Cherokee. For more detailed comparisons, visit the Consumer Reports SUV Guide.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is The Jeep Cherokee Reliable For Long-term Use?

No, the Cherokee has below-average reliability. Many owners report transmission and electrical issues that can become expensive after a few years.

How Does The Jeep Cherokee Compare With Other Suvs?

The Cherokee ranks lower in reliability, safety, and fuel economy compared to the Toyota RAV4, Honda CR-V, and Mazda CX-5.

Are Jeep Cherokee Repairs Expensive?

Yes, maintenance and repairs cost more than most competitors. Common problems like transmission and sensor failures can require costly fixes.

Does The Jeep Cherokee Have Good Resale Value?

No, the Cherokee depreciates quickly. You’ll get less money when selling compared to other SUVs like the RAV4 or CR-V.

What Is The Fuel Economy Of The Jeep Cherokee?

Most models get around 22 mpg city and 30 mpg highway, which is lower than many competitors. Over time, you’ll spend more on fuel.

Choosing the right SUV can save you money and stress. The Jeep Cherokee has too many weaknesses for most buyers.

If you want a vehicle that’s reliable, safe, and affordable, look at other options. Making an informed choice will give you peace of mind and better value.

Why Not To Buy A Jeep Cherokee: Top Reasons to Avoid

Photo of author
Hi there, my name is Nikola. I've spent more than a decade covered in grease and with a big smile on my face, as I've been exploring everything that has an engine. Although Jeeps are my favorite, I have a deep love for all things automotive.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.