Are you having some issues with the automatic transmission on your Jeep and you are asking yourself what are the common Jeep Wrangler automatic transmission shifting problems? If that’s correct, you are in the right place because, in this article, there will be a lot to cover.
Is your automatic transmission having trouble shifting? Some quick fixes you can try include topping off the ATF fluid, replacing the filter, and using an OBD2 sensor to diagnose solenoid or wiring issues. After pinpointing the source, replace the faulty component to get your Jeep back up and running.
Doing your research on a certain problem is always a good idea. We are saying this from our long experience wrenching on cars. Mechanics out there will find a thousand ways to rip you off, which is why you need to start understanding more about car problems and how to diagnose them.
And since you are already here you are on the right track because we will cover every possible gear-shifting problem on your Jeep.
But first, we are going to learn what an automatic transmission is and how it works. Then we are going to cover all of the Jeep Wrangler automatic transmission shifting problems and see how and when they appear.
Once we clear that out of our way, we are going to learn how you can fix these problems, as well as the costs involved in this process. So, without further ado, let’s dive into the topic.
What Is An Automatic Transmission?
Now before we learn more about the Jeep Wrangler’s automatic transmission shifting problems, let’s first learn more about the basics. What is an automatic transmission in your Jeep and how do these transmissions operate?
A car transmission in simple words is a big energy converter that every car with an internal combustion engine has. Transmissions are essential for the operation of the vehicle. Without a transmission, the car will not operate.
The transmission has the purpose of converting the rotational energy of the crankshaft into something that can be used on a day-to-day basis.
There are two main types of transmissions. These are the manual and the automatic transmissions. In this article, we are only interested in the automatic.
As its name implies, automatic transmission is a type of transmission that operates automatically. In other words, it does everything by itself.
The main task of the driver is to put the transmission into gear and the transmission will do everything it should. But how does this device work? What creates all the magic? Well, let’s elaborate more on that in the following chapter.
How Does An Automatic Transmission Work?
Another topic that we would like to elaborate on before we dive into the Jeep Wrangler automatic transmission shifting problems is the operation of the automatic transmission.
Jeeps use transmissions that are known as torque converter automatics or as some people call them classic automatics. This is an automatic transmission that is fitted with a fluid coupling device. Also known as a torque converter.
The torque converter is basically a big circular box filled with transmission fluid and this device increases the torque, as well as preventing engine stall at low RPM.
Overall, the whole operation of the transmission is done hydraulically. In other words with the help of hydraulic fluid.
This red fluid is crucial when it comes to the proper operation of your transmission. Every time you give input to the transmission, there are electronic devices known as solenoids that operate and turn on and off.
These devices allow this ATF fluid to go where there is a need for the transmission to deliver proper shifts.
These solenoids are attached to a component known as a valve body. As its name implies, this is a maze-like structure with valves through which the fluid travels around constantly depending on which solenoid/valve is engaged.
And lastly, when there is enough hydraulic pressure, the transmission will shift to the next gear up or down.
Overall, transmissions can be scary to understand at first, but once you get to know the operation better you will also understand the Jeep Wrangler automatic transmission shifting problems. And that’s what we are going to discuss next.
Jeep Wrangler Automatic Transmission Shifting Problems: 6 Reasons Why
Now let’s dive into the Jeep Wrangler automatic transmission shifting problems. Let’s list each one of them first and then we are going to delve into the details.
- Delayed Or Failed Gear Shifting
- Delayed/Failed Gear Engagement
- Slipping Gears/Erratic Shifts
- Transmission Randomly Shifts To Neutral
- Torque Converter/Overdrive Problems
- Transmission Leaks Fluid
So, we listed the most common Jeep Wrangler automatic transmission problems. Now it is time to further elaborate on each of these problems and learn when and how they appear.
Each of these issues creates different symptoms. So, it is worth elaborating on them and trying to understand more about each one of them in detail. Then, we can move on to the possible fixes for each of these problems that appear in your Jeep Wrangler.
1. Delayed Or Failed Gear Shifting
Now let’s start with the first situation that is most common when you are experiencing Jeep Wrangler automatic transmission shifting problems. This is the case when you experience delayed or failed transmission shifts.
This can be a pretty annoying problem to deal with. Because you will get a delayed response or no response at all from the transmission. Which can result in potentially dangerous situations on the road.
When it comes to the Jeep Wrangler, the most common transmissions having this problem are the 42RE and the 42RLE. These are 4-speed automatics used in the older models of the Wrangler.
The problem itself happens in specific situations. The most common situations are the cases when the transmission shifts from second to third or from third to fourth gear.
This problem can be difficult to diagnose, mainly because it does not often carry many symptoms. But here are some of the possibilities.
- Dirty transmission fluid can prevent the solenoids from opening and closing correctly.
- Low transmission fluid can also prevent proper solenoid work.
- A damaged or possibly blocked solenoid can also cause issues like this because there will be no fluid pressure.
- Poor wiring can also cause this problem, there are a lot of wires that go through these solenoids and sometimes wiring can fail as well.
- Worn-out bands can also cause problems like the one in this case.
- A bad overdrive solenoid is another very common cause for this problem when you experience failed or delayed shifts.
2. Delayed/Harsh Gear Engagement
Another very common situation that can indicate Jeep Wrangler automatic transmission shifting problems is the case when you have a delayed or harsh gear engagement.
This problem often appears in Jeeps that come with the 545RFE transmission. This is the 5-speed automatic transmission.
And luckily in this situation, there will be a check engine light on the cluster to notify you that you have a problem with your Jeep.
And even if the Jeep does not show a check engine light, the problem is easily detectable because it often happens in really cold weather.
Also, these problems often occur when the transmission shifts between 3-4 and 4-5 gears.
Common causes for this issues are the following:
- Transmission fluid leaks. The transmission fluid also known as ATF can leak fluid and when you have leaks, the transmission will not work as it should. Usually, the component that leaks this coolant is the transmission fluid cooler, fluid lines, or transmission oil pan.
- Valve body failure is another very common cause for this problem because of poor material for the check balls.
- Dirty transmission fluid can also cause problems such as this.
- Improper transmission fluid level can also cause a problem like this.
3. Slipping Gears/Erratic Shifts
Slipping gears and erratic shifts are other of the Jeep Wrangler’s automatic transmission shifting problems. This problem probably happens most often in automatic transmissions.
So, when a car slips gears it means that it drops a gear or shifts into a higher gear when it shouldn’t be doing so.
For example, you drive on the highway in fourth gear and the transmission suddenly drops a gear and the redline of your Wrangler goes to the max RPM.
This is a situation that you definitely want to avoid happening because it can be dangerous. Especially the second situation when the car shifts gears erratically. For example, instead of going into third gear, it goes into fourth.
These problems happen mostly in the newer A6MF1 6-speed automatic transmissions. Usually, whenever you have issues such as this, you will also get a check engine light.
So, what could be causing this problem? These are the main causes for slipping gears and erratic shifts:
- Broken solenoids are one of the most common causes of this type of situation. If the solenoid malfunctions, it will trigger a problem and the car will start to slip gears. These components have only one way to be sorted out and that is by replacement.
- Another cause can be a poor connection between the TCM and the solenoid wiring. Wires can get damaged from heat or other contaminants and cause interruptions and the solenoids can malfunction.
4. Transmission Randomly Shifts To Neutral
Another on our list of Jeep Wrangler automatic transmission shifting problems is the case when the transmission shifts randomly into neutral.
And this can be a very frustrating problem. Especially to the owners of the ZF 9-speed automatic. This is the transmission that is most plagued with these problems.
When this problem happens there will be a check engine light that is associated with the issue and this check engine light is usually P0901.
This transmission is plagued with problems and this is one of the most common issues. So, what could be causing it? Let’s find out.
Problem with the wiring harness. This problem is caused because of an improper crimp on the wiring harness that is attached to the sensor cluster. This controls the shift pattern and quality.
There were more than 500,000 cars that were recalled in the US because of this problem and was reportedly solved by installing a software upgrade by the dealership.
5. Torque Converter/Overdrive Problems
Another very common problem when it comes to the Jeep Wrangler automatic transmission shifting problems is the issue with the torque converter and overdrive.
This is a very common problem with 4-speed automatics like the 42RE and the 43RLE. These problems can be very frustrating because an issue like this is often associated with slipping gears and transmission shudder.
Usually, every problem that has the root inside of the torque converter is associated with these symptoms. But sometimes there can be other causes if these symptoms develop randomly.
The following causes can often trigger the torque converter or overdrive issue in your Jeep:
- The cover plate that is holding the boost valve can cause this issue. Specifically when it gets damaged, it can also damage its retaining bracket. And when this happens this bracket will not hold the lockup pump anymore. This situation will trigger a P1740 code.
- Another possibility is a bad speed sensor. This sensor is crucial when it comes to the throttle response. There can be a few of these speed sensors and this problem is only solved by using a code reader and a multimeter.
6. Transmission Leaks Fluid
Fluid leaks are another of the causes of Jeep Wrangler automatic transmission shifting problems. And a really important one because if these leaks are too serious the whole operation of the transmission will be under question.
This is because if you don’t have transmission fluid in your vehicle, the transmission will start to malfunction. And this is most often the root cause for the Jeep Wrangler TJ automatic transmission shifting problems.
This is why we often recommend that you inspect the transmission for leaks before you decide to throw a lot of money into expensive repairs.
These leaks can develop from the following places:
- The most common place for leaks is the oil transmission pan. This oil pan often leaks on many cars and causes many of these situations.
- Fluid lines can also leak and cause Jeep Wrangler JK automatic transmission shifting problems. There are fluid lines that go from the transmission to the cooler and they also tend to leak.
- A torque converter can also leak fluid. The torque converter as we noted is the big fluid coupling device.
- Transmission fluid coolers can also leak and cause these issues.
- Broken seals can also cause the transmission to lose fluid. There are a couple of seals on the input shaft and output shaft that can allow fluid to leak.
How To Fix Jeep Wrangler Automatic Transmission Shifting Problems?
Now let’s take a look at how to fix these Jeep Wrangler automatic transmission shifting problems. What can you do to solve these problems on your Jeep?
The first thing that you can do in these cases is to make sure that you have enough ATF fluid. You can check this while the transmission is hot.
You can inspect the level of the transmission only while the transmission is hot and then see if this level is good. On cold transmission, you will get the wrong readings.
When you check the transmission, top it off if the level is low and this in many cases will solve the problem. If the fluid is dirty and has metallic flakes and looks burnt you have to replace the fluid, as well as the filter.
If this doesn’t help, you have a more serious issue. This issue is often caused by bad solenoids or poor wiring.
For this, you will need to do deeper troubleshooting with a special OBD2 scanner tool. This tool will give you the codes.
Explore our handpicked selection of meticulously tested OBD2 scanners, curated by experts to empower you with the knowledge to make an informed and confident decision.
We present our exclusive recommendations to assist you in finding the perfect OBD2 scanner for your needs:
- LAUNCH OBD2 Scanner
- MOTOPOWER OBD2 Scanner
- FOXWELL NT201 OBD2 Scanner
- TOPDON AD800BT OBD2 Scanner
- BlueDriver Bluetooth Pro OBD2
Then when you get the codes, you will have an input on which sensor or solenoid to check. You can decide to replace it altogether. Or if you want to dive into deep troubleshooting, you can inspect each solenoid with a multimeter and see if they are operating properly.
Usually, this requires a lot of skill and know-how. This is why if you are a beginner, this job is not for you. Take your Jeep to the nearest dealership and let them sort out the issue for you.
What Is the Cost of Repairing Automatic Transmission Shifting Issues?
The cost to fix these Jeep Wrangler JL Automatic Transmission shifting problems can vary depending on the problem.
But in the best case, you can pay about $150 for a flush, and in the worst case, you can pay up to $500 for a solenoid replacement. These prices are for the parts and labor.
Conclusion
In this article, we covered quite a lot when it comes to the Jeep Wrangler’s automatic transmission shifting problems. First, we learned what an automatic transmission is and how it works. Then we elaborated on all of the causes of the shifting problems.
But can they be solved?
Well, in many cases, yes, just top off the fluid or flush the transmission fluid and you will be good.
But if this doesn’t solve the problem, unfortunately, the problem most often lies in some of the solenoids, valve bodies, or possibly the torque converter. Besides that, the internals of the transmission should be good, so no worries there.
If you want to learn more about other Jeep problems, make sure that you check the difference between the Jeep app vs. the Uconnect app.
Last update on 2025-10-17 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API
